Document Type

Article

Publication Date

10-2014

Publication Details

This article was originally published as:

de Berg, K. C. (2014). Teaching chemistry for all its worth: The interaction between facts, ideas, and language in Lavoisier's and Priestley's chemistry practice: The case of the study of the composition of air. Science and Education, 23(10), 2045-2068. doi:10.1007/s11191-014-9712-z

ISSN: 0926-7220

ANZSRC / FoR Code

039999 Chemical Sciences not elsewhere classified| 130212 Science, Technology and Engineering Curriculum and Pedagogy| 220206 History and Philosophy of Science (incl. Non-historical Philosophy of Science)

Abstract

Both Lavoisier and Priestley were committed to the role of experiment and observation in their chemistry practice. According to Lavoisier the physical sciences embody three important ingredients; facts, ideas, and language, and Priestley would not have disagreed with this. Ideas had to be consistent with the facts generated from experiment and observation and language needed to be precise and reflect the known chemistry of substances. While Priestley was comfortable with a moderate amount of hypothesis making, Lavoisier had no time for what he termed theoretical speculation about the fundamental nature of matter and avoided the use of the atomic hypothesis and Aristotle’s elements in his Elements of Chemistry. In the preface to this famous work he claims he has good educational reasons for this position. While Priestley and Lavoisier used similar kinds of apparatus in their chemistry practice, they came to their task with completely different worldviews as regards the nature of chemical reactivity. This paper examines these worldviews as practiced in the famous experiment on the composition of air and the implications of this for chemistry education are considered.

Comments

Used by permission: Springer and the authors.

The document available for download is the pre-published version of the article.The final publication of the article is available here.

Included in

Chemistry Commons

Share

COinS